PGT Winguard vs. Non-Impact Windows: Which is the Better Choice?

by Impact Windows Center December 31, 2023

When it comes to safeguarding your home, the choices can be overwhelming. Yet, the decision between PGT Winguard and Non-Impact windows is a critical one that affects not just the safety of your home, but also its energy efficiency, aesthetics, and even your wallet. Let's break down the differences and help you make an informed choice that aligns with your needs and preferences.

Choosing the Right Barrier: PGT Winguard and Non-Impact Windows

Windows are more than just glass and frames; they are a home's eyes to the world and its first line of defense against the elements. PGT Winguard and Non-Impact windows each offer unique benefits. Impact windows provide robust protection against storms and intruders, while non-impact windows offer traditional style and functionality. Your decision will hinge on factors like location, budget, and personal priorities.

Understanding PGT Winguard Windows

Design and Materials

PGT Winguard windows are engineered with strength in mind. They feature heavy-duty frames and laminated glass that resists breaking even under direct impact. This combination not only stands up to severe weather but also deters would-be burglars. The materials used are rigorously tested to ensure they meet high standards of durability and performance.

Heavy-duty aluminum or vinyl frames for maximum strength
Laminated glass designed to stay intact on impact
Advanced weatherstripping for superior weather resistance
High-quality hardware that complements the window's strength
Multiple design options to match your home's aesthetic

Impact Resistance Levels

PGT Winguard windows are synonymous with resilience. They're built to withstand the fury of hurricane-force winds and flying debris, giving you peace of mind when the weather turns fierce. These windows are tested to meet the most stringent codes, ensuring that they can protect your home in the toughest conditions.

Energy Efficiency and UV Protection

Beyond their brawn, PGT Winguard windows offer excellent energy efficiency. They help to regulate your home's temperature, keeping it cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. This can lead to significant savings on energy bills. Moreover, the UV protection they provide helps to prevent fading of your furniture, carpets, and curtains, preserving the interior of your home.

Insulated glass options that reduce heat transfer
Low-E coatings that reflect UV rays
ENERGY STAR ratings on select models
Reduced energy bills through improved insulation
Long-term savings and comfort

Exploring Non-Impact Window Options

Construction and Durability

Non-impact windows may not offer the same level of protection as PGT Winguard, but they are by no means fragile. These windows are constructed with quality materials and craftsmanship. They are a solid choice for areas not prone to severe weather, providing a traditional look without sacrificing durability.

Cost-Effectiveness for Mild Climates

In regions where hurricanes and violent storms are less of a concern, non-impact windows can be a more cost-effective solution. They still offer good performance and energy efficiency, with the added benefit of a lower initial investment. It's a practical option for homeowners who want quality windows without the added cost of impact-resistant features.

Affordable without compromising on quality
Good insulation properties
Variety of styles to fit any home design
Easy to repair or replace if necessary
Ample natural light and visibility

Customization and Style Variations

One of the joys of selecting new windows is the ability to tailor them to your home's unique style. Non-impact windows shine in this aspect, offering a wide array of customizations. From grid patterns to frame colors, and from classic double-hung to sleek picture windows, the options are plentiful. This flexibility allows homeowners to express their style while enhancing their home's curb appeal.

Vast selection of frame colors and finishes
Grid patterns and decorative glass options
Choice of window styles, including bay, bow, and slider
Custom sizing for unique window openings
Hardware finishes to complement your home's interior

Crucial Factors in Window Selection

Choosing the right windows for your home is more than just picking out a style. It's about weighing the benefits and costs, understanding the value they add, and ensuring they meet your safety needs. Let's dive into the factors that should guide your decision-making process.

Initial Investment and Long-Term Value

When you're budgeting for new windows, consider both the short-term and long-term financial implications. The initial cost is just the beginning. Think about energy savings, maintenance, and how the windows will affect your home's value over time. Quality windows are an investment that can pay off in numerous ways.

Cost Comparison: Upfront and Ongoing

Impact windows, like PGT Winguard, often come with a higher price tag upfront due to their reinforced construction. However, they can lead to savings on energy bills and may require less maintenance over time due to their durability. Non-impact windows, while less expensive initially, might not offer the same energy savings or long-term resilience.

Resale Value and Insurance Premiums

Installing impact windows can increase your home's resale value and may lead to lower insurance premiums, especially in storm-prone areas. Insurers often recognize the added protection these windows provide and may reward homeowners with discounts. This is a financial benefit that should not be overlooked when considering the total value of your window investment.

Safety and Storm Protection

Your family's safety is paramount, and the right windows play a crucial role in protecting against external threats. Whether it's from severe weather or potential intruders, windows designed with safety in mind offer priceless peace of mind.

Comparing Wind and Debris Resistance

PGT Winguard windows are designed to stand up to high winds and flying debris, a must-have in hurricane zones. Non-impact windows, while sturdy, do not offer the same level of protection. If you live in an area where storms are a concern, the superior resistance of impact windows could be a deciding factor.

Building Code Considerations by Region

Building codes vary by region and often dictate the type of windows required for new construction or major renovations. In hurricane-prone areas, codes may require impact-resistant windows. It's essential to be aware of these regulations to ensure your home is compliant and protected.

Comfort and Living Quality

Your home is your sanctuary, and the right windows contribute significantly to its comfort and ambiance. Whether it's the peace that comes from a quiet interior or the cozy warmth on a chilly day, the windows you choose have a direct impact on your daily living experience.

Noise Reduction Capabilities

Imagine a serene morning without the interruption of traffic noise or the neighbor's lawn mower. PGT Winguard windows offer excellent noise reduction, turning your home into a peaceful haven. The laminated glass not only protects against impacts but also dampens sound, making it an ideal choice for homes in busy areas or near airports.

Significant decrease in external noise infiltration
A peaceful home environment, even in noisy neighborhoods
Laminated glass serves as a sound barrier
Improved quality of life with reduced stress and distractions

Tinting Options and Thermal Insulation

Control over the sun's glare and heat is not only about comfort but also about energy efficiency. Both PGT Winguard and Non-Impact windows offer tinting options that can reduce heat gain and protect your privacy. Additionally, thermal insulation features help to maintain a consistent indoor temperature, cutting down on heating and cooling costs.

Tinted glass for privacy and reduced glare
Thermal insulation for year-round comfort
Lower energy consumption and utility bills
Protection from harmful UV rays

Final Thoughts on Window Wisdom

Windows are more than just glass and frames; they're the guardians of your home. They let in light, keep out the weather, and protect against the unexpected. Whether you choose PGT Winguard or non-impact windows, the right choice depends on your unique situation. But remember, the best window is the one that meets your needs for safety, efficiency, and style.

Key Considerations for Lasting Satisfaction

Long-term satisfaction with your windows comes down to a few key factors. Think about the climate you live in, the level of maintenance you're willing to undertake, and the performance you expect. Consider the warranty, the reputation of the manufacturer, and the quality of installation. These considerations will guide you to windows that offer satisfaction for years to come.

Top Picks Based on Climate and Needs

Your location and lifestyle should dictate your window choice. In hurricane zones, PGT Winguard windows are a smart pick for their unparalleled protection. In milder climates, high-quality non-impact windows can offer the comfort and efficiency you need. Assess your local weather patterns, your home's design, and your personal preferences to make the best choice for your sanctuary.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How do PGT Winguard windows differ from traditional hurricane shutters?

PGT Winguard windows and traditional hurricane shutters serve a similar purpose—protection against severe weather—but they differ significantly in design and functionality. Winguard windows are built-in and provide constant protection without the need for installation each time a storm approaches. They also offer improved aesthetics, noise reduction, and UV protection, which shutters cannot provide. On the other hand, hurricane shutters are often an add-on feature that requires manual setup before a storm and storage afterward.

Can non-impact windows be retrofitted to become impact-resistant?

Non-impact windows typically cannot be retrofitted to become impact-resistant due to the specific construction of impact-resistant glass and the structural reinforcement needed. However, there are aftermarket products, such as storm panels or impact-resistant films, that can offer an additional layer of protection. It's important to note that these solutions may not meet the same standards as factory-made impact windows like PGT Winguard.

What is the lifespan of PGT Winguard windows compared to non-impact windows?

PGT Winguard windows are designed for longevity and can last as long as non-impact windows when properly maintained, often several decades. The exact lifespan will vary based on factors like environmental conditions, maintenance, and usage. However, the durable construction of Winguard windows may give them an edge in harsher climates where they're subjected to more stress from wind and debris.

Are there any insurance benefits to choosing impact-resistant windows?

Yes, homeowners can often enjoy insurance benefits when choosing impact-resistant windows. Many insurance companies offer discounts on premiums for homes equipped with features that reduce the risk of damage from severe weather, including impact-resistant windows. These discounts can result in significant savings over time, offsetting the initial investment in windows like PGT Winguard.

Choosing the right windows for your home is a decision that impacts not only the look and feel of your living space but also its safety, energy efficiency, and value. Whether you opt for the robust protection of PGT Winguard windows or the traditional elegance of non-impact windows, ensure your choice aligns with your location's weather challenges, your style, and your long-term comfort and satisfaction. Armed with the right information and a clear understanding of your needs, you can make a decision that will stand the test of time and bring peace of mind for years to come.