Hurricane Doors vs. Storm Shutters: My Take on What Works Best for Tampa Homes
Living in Tampa means I get to enjoy sunshine, coastal breezes, and warm weather most of the year. But it also means I have to prepare for hurricane season every June through November. Those high winds, heavy rains, and flying debris can do serious damage to a home—and the most vulnerable points are almost always the windows and doors.
When it comes to protecting them, the two most common options I see are hurricane impact doors and storm shutters. Both can work well in a storm, but they function very differently and come with their pros and cons.
If you’re trying to decide which is best for your Tampa home, here’s how I compare hurricane doors and storm shutters in terms of protection, cost, convenience, and long-term value.
What I Like About Hurricane Doors
Hurricane doors—also called impact-resistant doors—are specially engineered with reinforced frames and laminated glass to stand up to hurricane-force winds and flying debris. They meet strict Florida Building Code standards, including the rigorous requirements set by Miami-Dade County.
Unlike a standard door, a hurricane door has two layers of glass bonded with a clear, ultra-strong interlayer. If debris hits, the outer glass might crack, but the interlayer keeps everything intact—blocking wind, rain, and projectiles from getting inside.
How Storm Shutters Work
Storm shutters are coverings installed over doors and windows when a storm is approaching. I’ve seen all types, including:
-
Accordion shutters
-
Roll-down shutters
-
Colonial-style shutters
-
Removable panel shutters
-
Fabric storm panels
They’re usually made of metal, polycarbonate, or other durable materials, and they physically shield your glass from damage. Some deploy manually, others electronically.
Protection & Performance
Both hurricane doors and storm shutters can protect your home—but hurricane doors have a few big advantages.
Hurricane doors are always ready. There’s no last-minute setup, no tools, no climbing ladders in bad weather. They’re permanently installed, meet strict wind- and impact-resistance standards, and protect against more than just storms—they also deter break-ins and block UV damage.
Shutters, on the other hand, work only if you remember to install or close them in time. You also need to make sure they’re in good shape before the storm hits.
Everyday Look & Function
Hurricane impact doors bring year-round style and security. With sleek glass panels and clean framing, they let in natural light and boost curb appeal. Some, like the PGT WinGuard® sliding glass door, are perfect for patios and backyards, giving you wide-open views without sacrificing storm safety.
Shutters tend to be bulkier. Permanent ones can look industrial when not in use, and removable panels need to be stored, which means they take up garage or shed space.
Plus, hurricane doors serve as your regular entry or patio door every day—shutters are only useful during storms.
Cost Over Time
Yes, shutters usually cost less upfront, especially the manual or removable kinds. But you might end up buying a lot to cover every opening, plus paying for installation and occasional repairs.
Hurricane doors cost more initially, but it’s a one-time purchase for both your door and your storm protection. No seasonal removal, no storage, and minimal maintenance. They can also lower your homeowners' insurance premiums and may boost your home’s resale value.
Safety & Convenience in a Storm
When a hurricane’s on the way, speed matters. Hurricane doors are already in place and doing their job before, during, and after the storm.
Shutters take time and effort to deploy—unless you spring for motorized roll-downs, which cost more. And in an emergency, shutters can sometimes block visibility or exit access. Hurricane doors, meanwhile, work like any normal door at all times.
My Verdict for Tampa Homes
For most homeowners I work with, hurricane doors are the best all-around choice. They’re always ready, they look great, they make your home more secure, and they can save money in the long run.
Shutters are still a valid, budget-friendly option—especially as backup protection or for safeguarding windows when you already have impact doors.
Need Help Choosing?
If you’re building new or upgrading your storm protection, we offer a wide selection of hurricane-rated doors at Impact Windows Center here in Tampa—including the PGT WinGuard® sliding glass door. They’re made for Florida’s coastal climate and meet the toughest building standards in the state.